On May 24th of 1909 the cornerstone was laid at a service of dedication conducted by the Rev. Dr. D.D. McLeod of the Presbytery of Barrie and Rev. Lachlan McLean minister. Inspired by a church building on Fifth Avenue in New York City, the building was designed by Toronto architect James Thomson originally from Barrie. Through the course of the intervening years of the 20th century SPC has been associated with Essa Road Presbyterian Church. In the 1980s the congregation became self-supporting and, in 1990, called their first full-time minister, Rev. Doug Crocker.